Direct listing vs IPO vs SPAC: how each route to market works
An IPO sells new shares via underwriters, a direct listing lists existing shares, and a SPAC merges into a listed shell. Compared with real examples.
A company goes public in one of three main ways. An IPO sells new shares through underwriting banks at a set price. A direct listing puts existing shares on an exchange without underwriters pricing them. A SPAC merger sells the company to an already-listed shell.
The three routes in one table
| Traditional IPO | Direct listing | SPAC merger | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What happens | Company sells new shares via underwriters | Existing shares start trading on an exchange | Listed shell company acquires the private company |
| Price set by | Company and underwriters (bookbuilding) | Opening auction on the day | Private negotiation, shares valued at $10 in the deal |
| New money raised | Yes, usually | Not in the classic form; possible in a primary listing | Cash in the trust plus any PIPE, minus redemptions |
| Main fees | Underwriting spread on shares sold | Advisory fees, no spread on shares sold | Sponsor shares, warrants, advisory costs |
| Lock-up on insiders | Usually 180 days | Often none | Negotiated |
| Examples | Arm (2023), Reddit (2024) | Spotify (2018), Slack (2019), Coinbase (2021) | Virgin Galactic, DraftKings, SoFi |
How a traditional IPO works
In an IPO, the company files a registration statement with the SEC, markets the deal to institutions in a roadshow, and agrees an offer price with its underwriters the night before trading. Shares go to the buyers the banks choose. See how an IPO works and IPO share allocation.
Reddit priced its March 2024 IPO at $34 a share and closed its first day at $50.44, up about 48% (CNBC, TechCrunch). Arm priced at $51 in September 2023 and closed its first day at $63.59, up about 25%. The gap between offer and first-day close is the “money left on the table” covered in IPO first-day pop.
How a direct listing works
A direct listing lets existing shareholders sell shares on an exchange without a new share sale. There is no roadshow price. The exchange runs an opening auction, and the first trade price comes from buy and sell orders. A “reference price” is published as a starting guide.
Spotify listed on the NYSE in April 2018 and Slack in June 2019, both without raising capital in the listing. Coinbase direct-listed on Nasdaq in April 2021, with a reference price of $250 and an opening trade near $381 (widely reported).
Advantages: no underwriting spread, no automatic lock-up for most holders, and the market sets the price. Disadvantages: no new capital in the classic form, and no banks stabilizing the price or guaranteeing demand. Warby Parker (2021) is also often grouped with IPOs but used a direct listing (Quartz).
How a SPAC merger works
A special purpose acquisition company (SPAC) raises money in its own IPO with no business, holds the cash in trust, and then has about two years to find a private company to merge with. Shareholders can redeem their shares for cash at the deal, so the money that actually arrives depends on redemptions.
SPAC deals peaked in 2020 and 2021. Well-known examples include DraftKings (2020), Virgin Galactic (2019), SoFi and Lucid (both 2021). Many SPAC-merged shares later traded well below the $10 deal price. In January 2024 the SEC adopted rules requiring more disclosure and extending liability for SPAC deals, bringing them closer to a traditional IPO (SEC).
Which route fits which company
- IPO: companies that want to raise capital and want underwriters to build a shareholder base.
- Direct listing: well-known companies with plenty of cash and wide brand recognition, such as Spotify, that do not need new money.
- SPAC: companies seeking price certainty in a private deal, or an early-stage story that is hard to sell in a roadshow, accepting dilution from sponsor shares and warrants.
Our take: the large technology listings of the past few years have mostly used the traditional IPO. Check the IPO list for how the biggest ones performed, and see IPO lock-up periods for when insiders can sell afterwards.
Frequently asked questions
What is the main difference between a direct listing and an IPO?
An IPO creates new shares sold to investors at a price the underwriters set. A traditional direct listing lists existing shares and lets the opening auction set the price, with no new shares sold.
Which is cheapest, an IPO, direct listing or SPAC?
A direct listing avoids underwriting fees on new shares, so it can cost less in fees. SPAC deals carry sponsor shares and warrants that dilute other holders, so cost is not simply lower.
Why did SPACs fall out of favor after 2021?
Many SPAC-merged companies traded below the $10 deal price, redemptions rose, and the SEC adopted new SPAC disclosure and liability rules in January 2024.
Can a company raise money in a direct listing?
Since the SEC and exchanges approved primary direct listings, a company can sell new shares in the listing. Spotify, Slack and Coinbase were listings of existing shares, not capital raises.
Sources
- SEC. Special Purpose Acquisition Companies, Shell Companies, and Projections (final rules),
- TechCrunch. Reddit stock closes up nearly 48% on its first day of trading,
- CNBC. Reddit IPO: (RDDT) starts trading on NYSE,
- Quartz. 10 public benefit corporations tied to US stock market listings,
- Jay R. Ritter, University of Florida. Initial Public Offerings: Underwriting Statistics,
Information only, not investment advice. Figures are from public sources; tiers show how solid each one is. How we source figures.